| oddBar. | 9.1 | $22.60 | St. Catharines |
| Volcano Pizzeria | 9.1 | $18.07 | St. Catharines |
| Boss Pizza | 9.1 | $31.00 | St. Catharines |
| Johnny Rocco's Italian Grill | 9 | $17.52 | St. Catharines |
| Pie Guys Tap And Grill | 9 | $20.62 | St. Catharines |
| Cafe Amore | 8.9 | $18.36 | St. Catharines |
| Pete's Pizza | 8.9 | $19.76 | St. Catharines |
| Fat Louie's American Style Pizzeria & Bar | 8.7 | $18.07 | St. Catharines |
| Volcanos Pizzeria | 8.6 | $18.07 | St. Catharines |
| The Twisted Pig | 8.6 | $21.47 | St. Catharines |
| Olee's Ale House | 8.6 | $15.82 | St. Catharines |
| Fat Louie's Pizzeria & Bar | 8.5 | $19.20 | St. Catharines |
| Pete's Pizza Lakeshore | 8.5 | $19.20 | St. Catharines |
| Rollin' Pizza Handcrafted Pizza + Pasta | 8.4 | $25.43 | St. Catharines |
| Pie Guys Pizzeria Linwell | 8.4 | $20.62 | St. Catharines |
| Restaurant 88 | 8.4 | $17.94 | St. Catharines |
| Fabio's | 8.3 | $17.52 | St. Catharines |
| Big Marco's Italian Restaurant | 8.3 | $17.00 | St. Catharines |
| Kully's Original Sports Bar | 8.3 | $33.89 | St. Catharines |
| 13th Street Winery | 8.3 | $18.08 | St. Catharines |
| Tony's Pizzeria | 8.2 | $17.80 | St. Catharines |
| Manhattan Bar & Grill | 8.2 | $18.05 | St. Catharines |
| Mezzano's Pizza | 8.1 | $14.70 | St. Catharines |
| Julius Pizza | 8.1 | $16.10 | St. Catharines |
| Buddy's Pizza | 8.1 | $14.68 | St. Catharines |
| Papa Vince Pizza | 8.1 | $18.07 | St. Catharines |
| On the Marc Pizza | 8 | $14.45 | St. Catharines |
| Lina Linguini's Pasta & Grille | 7.9 | $18.07 | St. Catharines |
| Bella Noella's | 7.9 | $20.34 | St. Catharines |
| Bugsy's | 7.9 | $17.75 | St. Catharines |
| Pete's Pizza | 7.8 | $24.85 | St. Catharines |
| Maestro's Pizzeria | 7.8 | $14.68 | St. Catharines |
| Jo Blo's Bar & Grill | 7.8 | $20.84 | St. Catharines |
| Coppola's Ristorante | 7.8 | $20.34 | St. Catharines |
| Scorecard Harry's Inc | 7.8 | $27.63 | St. Catharines |
| Paesano Pizza | 7.8 | $13.00 | St. Catharines |
| Fat Cat's Pizza | 7.7 | $16.33 | St. Catharines |
| Merrittville Wood Fired Pizza | 7.7 | $15.80 | St. Catharines |
| Pizza Jerry's Union House | 7.7 | $18.11 | St. Catharines |
| Il Fornello | 7.7 | $18.65 | St. Catharines |
| Pizza Hut Stuffed Crust | 7.6 | $25.13 | St. Catharines |
| Westside Pizzeria & Bar | 7.6 | $20.25 | St. Catharines |
| Cracker Jack's Bar & Grill | 7.6 | $20.91 | St. Catharines |
| Alligator Pear | 7.6 | $20.34 | St. Catharines |
| The Pizza Company | 7.5 | $16.39 | St. Catharines |
| Paesano Pizza | 7.4 | $13.95 | St. Catharines |
| Big Brothers Gourrmet Pizza | 7.4 | $14.68 | St. Catharines |
| Caffe Gatti | 7.4 | $33.90 | St. Catharines |
| Monty's Gastropub | 7.4 | $15.82 | St. Catharines |
| AJ'S Pie | 7.3 | $18.35 | St. Catharines |
| Peppinos Pizzeria | 7.3 | $16.90 | St. Catharines |
| Lazy Lizard | 7.3 | $18.06 | St. Catharines |
| Antipastos | 7.3 | $20.88 | St. Catharines |
| Carson's Pizzaria | 7.2 | $28.24 | St. Catharines |
| Gino's Pizza | 7.1 | $12.42 | St. Catharines |
| Pitcher's Sports Bar And Grill | 7.1 | $16.33 | St. Catharines |
| Domino's Pizza | 7.1 | $14.11 | St. Catharines |
| Boston Pizza | 6.8 | $27.96 | St. Catharines |
| Cat's Caboose | 6.8 | $22.58 | St. Catharines |
| St Catharines Pizza Company | 6.7 | $14.53 | St. Catharines |
| Pizza House | 6.6 | $16.84 | St. Catharines |
| Super 241 Pizza | 6.5 | $9.05 | St. Catharines |
| Fresco's Euro Grille | 6.4 | $18.07 | St. Catharines |
| Italia Pizzeria | 6.2 | $11.29 | St. Catharines |
| Twice The Deal Pizza | 6.2 | $9.05 | St. Catharines |
| Little Caesars The Batman Calzone | 5.7 | $11.29 | St. Catharines |
| Stromboli's Pizza | 5.7 | $16.61 | St. Catharines |
| Score Pizza | 5.2 | $11.87 | St. Catharines |
| Metro Lakeshore | 5.2 | $12.42 | St. Catharines |
| Papa John's Pizza | 5.1 | $14.68 | St. Catharines |
| The Overtime Pub | 4.7 | $16.33 | St. Catharines |
| Qualia Pizza | 4.4 | $13.55 | St. Catharines |
| Red Swan Pizza Keto Crust | 4.3 | $21.41 | St. Catharines |
| Wild Wing | 4.2 | $10.86 | St. Catharines |
| Wrigley's Sports Bar | 4.1 | $16.94 | St. Catharines |
| 7-Eleven | 3.4 | $12.98 | St. Catharines |
| Pizza Pizza | 2.3 | $10.72 | St. Catharines |
